Pinch of Mint · www.pinchofmint.com/recipes/eggs-benedict
- One pan
Eggs Benedict from scratch

By Tom · Updated
- About 3 hours 15 min
- One to take your time over
Anyway, whenever you decide to eat it, it is definitely one of my favourites. In this recipe tutorial I demonstrate how to make eggs Benedict completely from scratch. From homemade English muffins to a beautifully rich hollandaise sauce and of course, perfect poached eggs.
Loads from YouTube only once you press play.
The recipe
Eggs Benedict from scratch
Anyway, whenever you decide to eat it, it is definitely one of my favourites.
- 20 min prep
- 24 min cooking
- 2 hours 31 min hands-off
- One to take your time over
Times and difficulty are our estimates from the method, not stopwatch figures.
Ingredients
Hollandaise reduction ingredients
Hollandaise sauce ingredients
Tick things off as you go — they stay ticked if you close the page.
A dotted underline means the amount has been rounded to something you can measure.
Method
- Step 1
Warm the milk (200 ml) and butter (20 g) in a saucepan over low heat until the butter melts and the milk is lukewarm.
- Step 2
Place the flour (270 g) in a mixing bowl and make a well in the centre. Place the dried yeast (3½ g) on one side and salt (3 g) on the other.
- Step 3
Pour the milk (200 ml) mixture into the centre. Mix to form a dough. Knead for 5 to 10 minutes until smooth and stretchy. Roll it into a ball and cover it with a damp cloth. Cover and prove for 1 hour.
- Step 4
Divide the dough into 7 equal portions, roll into balls, and place onto a baking sheet dusted with semolina. Sprinkle semolina over the dough balls and firmly press each one down. Cover and prove for 1 to 1.5 hours.
- Step 5
Place a frying pan over medium-low heat. Once hot place in the muffins (you may need to do this in batches) and cook for 7 to 8 minutes on each side until golden brown. Leave to cool before breaking open and enjoying.
Hollandaise reduction ingredients
- Step 1
Place the vinegar (150 ml), sliced shallot (1 shallot), thyme (2 thyme) and peppercorns (1 tsp) into a saucepan. Place over the heat and bring to a boil. Boil until the liquid reduces by half the amount. Pass through a sieve, save the liquid and discard the aromatics. Leave to cool before using.
Hollandaise sauce ingredients
- Step 1
Place a saucepan over the heat and bring to a gentle simmer. Place 1 Tbsp of hollandaise reduction (1 tbsp) into a heatproof bowl and add in the egg yolks (2 yolks). Whisk together.
- Step 2
Place the bowl over the pan of simmering water and whisk continuously until the mixture becomes pale in colour, thick and almost doubled the size. Be careful not to scramble the eggs.
- Step 3
Take from the heat and gradually whisk in the clarified butter (200 g)/melted butter until fully incorporated. Season to taste with the juice of half a lemon and a pinch of salt (3 g).
Step 4: Poached eggs ingredients
Large Pan of Boiling Water.
- Step 5
1 Tbsp x White Wine Vinegar (150 ml).
- Step 6
Fresh Eggs.
- Step 7
Salt (3 g) & Pepper.
- Step 8
Bring the pan of water to a rolling boil and add in the vinegar (150 ml). Turn it down to a gentle simmer and crack your eggs into ramekins.
- Step 9
Place your eggs into the simmering water and set a 3 minute timer. After 3 minutes immediately remove from the water and place them onto a plate lined with kitchen towel to absorb the excess water. Season with salt (3 g) and pepper.
Step 10: To serve
Slices of Ham.
- Step 11
Crispy Streaky Bacon.
- Step 12
Cut your muffins in half and place onto a plate, topping them with slices of ham of your choice. Next, place on you poached eggs and cover with hollandaise sauce. Finish them with the crispy bacon and enjoy.
Stay in the loop
Get new recipes in your inbox
Occasional emails with new recipes, cooking tips and what’s new at Pinch of Mint.
See our Privacy Policy for information about how your personal data is used.
More eggs breakfasts
Also in Eggs, from poached to soufflé.
Questions people ask
How long does eggs benedict from scratch take?
About 3 hours 15 min from start to finish: 20 min of prep, 24 min of cooking, and 2 hours 31 min hands-off while it waits. That figure is worked out from the method rather than timed with a stopwatch, so give yourself a little more the first time.
How much does this make?
The original recipe did not state a yield, so nothing has been invented for it. The scale control on the recipe card multiplies the quantities instead, which is the honest version of the same thing.
Can I see the ingredients in ounces and pints?
Yes. The metric and imperial switch on the recipe card converts every quantity, rounded to amounts you can actually weigh or measure rather than to four decimal places. Your choice is remembered for every recipe on the site.
Is it vegetarian?
Yes, as written. If you are cooking for a strict vegetarian, the one to check is the cheese: several hard cheeses are made with animal rennet.
Eggs Benedict from scratch · Pinch of Mint · www.pinchofmint.com/recipes/eggs-benedict




